Hibbs Galivants on 10/3
Posted by: Brian Hibbs on November 10, 2010
Six books from last week which I have something to say about (though, maybe nothing interesting!), below the jump!
BATMAN AND ROBIN #16: Say what you want about Morrison’s Batman (some find it confusing), but he’s pulled a very neat trick here at the end in adding to the character, expanding the possibilities of the franchise, and doing so in a way that doesn’t invalidate anything before or (hopefully) after. I’m not sure that I can think of another run of a superhero book that so radically reinvents the premise of a character while zeroing-in on the core of the character so successfully. Well, no, maybe I can: Morrison’s own DOOM PATROL run, maybe, or Moore’s SWAMP THING (though that really isn’t superhero, per se) — I probably wouldn’t put Morrison’s ANIMAL MAN in that category though, because that was more about the meta, then Buddy Baker himself, per se. Either way, that little bombshell at the end of #16, which, presumably will be much expanded upon in the upcoming BATMAN, INC., is potentially a pretty big sea change for the Batman Mythos, and can, I suspect help keep the character relevant for a really long time.
The bigger question is how writers who don’t have the initials “G.M.” will fare with the concept. One thing that seems to happen with these kind of “sea changes” of the quo is that really only the originator knows just what do with it — witness, say, post-Moore SWAMP THING. Veitch’s run was terrific (but he was a Moore collaborator before that), but after that? No one whatsoever had a clue as to what to do with the “Earth Elemental” concept, and the grafting of the broader idea upon characters like Firestorm and Red Tornado turned out to have no legs whatsoever.
The difference, perhaps, in this case might lay in the “it’s ALL true” framework Morrison has been constructing — this move lets there be multiple versions and styles of Batman (I like Dick’s “laughing Batman”, personally), but if they each get as dull as the “average” Bruce-is story has been over the years, it isn’t going to help very much.
Either way, this direction is fairly genius, and gives me more hope for the future of the character than anything, really, ever. EXCELLENT stuff.
DOOM PATROL #16: I think it might be worth noting that Keith Giffen actually illustrated this issue (is he the new ongoing penciller?), and that’s just terrific. I’d pretty much forgotten how much I love his art. The story, with something or other about alternate universe versions of the DP wasn’t anything special, but at least it was a pretty and compelling nothing special. I do want to note that I’m not so sure that the idea of writing out the Chief, after he’d just be written back in, was anything better than a meandering diversion (See? Kind of the Morrison problem, again), but I think this issue is well worth seeking out — VERY GOOD.
GENERATION HOPE #1: Meh, I guess I get the desire to create the next new generation of X, but it strikes me that this worked much better as a background thread than as a premise for its own book. Plus, WTF was up with the completely blatant AKIRA rip-off? That made me want to never read this book again… EH.
SCARLET #3: the first two issues were fairly morally questionable (which is fine, seriously), but this one takes a sharp hard turn that veers closely into “repugnant”. The measure of craft on display here means that I still liked it, but I’m questioning, in my own head, if this can go anywhere that I want to follow. Questioning is good, sometimes, though — a solidly GOOD comic.
STRANGE TALES 2 #2: My first thought: if it didn’t get in the way of his doing his “real” work, I’d be way way down with a monthly Marvel comic by the Hernandez brothers. I loved each and every inch of both Jaime and Gilbert’s stories.
My second thought: WTF was up with that “Ghost Badge” story? I literally couldn’t figure out why it was being published in this anthology, or what it had to do with Marvel comics. The fact it wasn’t very good didn’t help matters.
My third thought: isn’t it really really deeply weird that “Alternative” cartoonists do a better job presenting a pretty much “all ages” Marvel comic than the “real” Marvel creators do?
Either way: this is some fine comics — except for the Ghost Badge story, which drags the whole thing down to a mere VERY GOOD.
SUPERBOY #1: I don’t know that I need or want a “Superboy” comic, but if we’re going to have one, this would seem to be the way to do it — Smallville-based, pretty fun, relatively teen-angsty. I thought this was a GOOD solid start.
As always, what did YOU think?