Things That Actually Happened This Week: Graeme Really Manages To Review Some 6/22 Books

Graeme McMillan

Why, if it’s Monday, then it’s capsule reviews. And, for once, proper capsule reviews about books that came out on Wednesday! How did that happen? (Also, scroll down for John’s reviews, and then down some more for the shipping list. Yes, it’s a surprisingly busy Monday here, for once.)

ACTION COMICS #902: Oh, look. I really like Paul Cornell, and I can kind of see what he’s going for here – The big, epic return to Metropolis and Action Comics, with Lois saying things like “He’ll save us or die trying” and Superman stopping the unstoppably falling spaceship from crushing Metropolis – but… it’s just not working, somehow. Everything’s feeling very rushed, and the art isn’t helping sell the scale of it in the slightest. I’m not sure what’s wrong with it, exactly, but it’s just Eh when it should be much, much better.

BATMAN: GATES OF GOTHAM #2: I’m still unsure why this is a stand-alone mini, aside from the need to get this story finished before Dick stops being Batman again. That said, it’s weirdly enjoyable, if very familiar to anyone who’s been reading Batman comics for as long as I have. Does anyone remember “Destroyer,” in which a villain was destroying Gotham’s buildings to – and this was admittedly a ridiculous moment even for 1990s comics – reveal the Anton Furst-designed architecture that somehow still existed underneath? If you liked that story, chances are, you’ll like this one, because it’s essentially the same plot but with slicker execution and more Bat-family characters. Maybe that’s why they kept Bruce out of it, because he’d have a terrible sense of deja vu. Anyway, Okay.

BRIGHTEST DAY AFTERMATH: THE SEARCH FOR SWAMP THING #1: I’m tempted to say “What Hibbs said,” but I read this after reading a comp of Flashpoint: The Canterbury Cricket, and that book is so bad that this genuinely looks a lot better by comparison. But, yes, this is a pretty Awful book, with Constantine’s accent going all over the place (“Now sodd off, ye tosser!” Why’s he saying “ye”?), one of the weirdest Batman portrayals in recent memory and a plot that really doesn’t hang together well at all. Considering we’re getting the reboot and a new Swamp Thing series in a couple of months, I really have no idea why this book exists other than to take up shelf space.

JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA #58: Despite the last page, I really enjoyed this issue, especially the way that James Robinson clearly loves DC mythology – He works Bob Haney’s Brave & Bold story where the Atom essentially works Batman’s body like a puppet from inside his head into continuity, which is easily the highlight of the issue – and there’s really something great about the incredibly expansive approach he’s taken to this book since taking over: Alan Scott has pretty much become part of the team, and seeing characters like the Manhattan Guardian and Knight and Squire even for wordless cameos still brings a sense of unity to the DCU that so many other books (and other takes on the JLA) have been missing. I’m not sure exactly where this story is going, with only a couple of issues left, but it’s been Good so far, and it’ll be a shame to lose this one in the relaunch.

SUPERMAN #712: Ignoring all the controversy about replacing the originally planned story for this issue with the shelved-for-five-years Kurt Busiek/Rick Leonardi story about Krypto dealing with the death of Superboy, I have to say: This broke my heart. Maybe it’s because I had a rough week last week with one of my dogs getting a corneal ulcer, leading to many hours in the animal hospital and a very depressed dog in between visits, but this issue completely destroyed me. Krypto howling for two pages because he can’t find his owners, and then running away to be sad on an asteroid? If that’s not the most upsetting thing I’ll read this year, I might just want to stop reading anything right now. Very Good, but maybe that’s entirely my own biases.

ULTIMATE DEATH OF SPIDER-MAN SPIDER-MAN #160: Wait, that is what the logo says, right? This was… underwhelming. I don’t know why, because it does do everything it promises: It totally kills Spider-Man. But it does so in such a way as make that seem not only inevitable – That was to be expected considering the title of the story, surely – but also entirely boring. There’s not only any sense of surprise here, there’s also no emotion… which feels surprising for a Bendis comic, especially this Bendis comic, but it’s true; all the angst and anguish feels rote, and everything feels generic and (no pun intended, I promise) lifeless. For someone who’s enjoyed this comic since it was relaunched – and before then, too, but especially since LaFuente and Pichelli came on as artists – this was a really depressing comic, but not for the reasons Marvel wanted it to be. Crap.

5 Responses to “ Things That Actually Happened This Week: Graeme Really Manages To Review Some 6/22 Books ”

  1. Very glad the Krypto story worked for you, sir!

  2. If it hadn’t carried the supertitle “Ultimate Death of Spider-Man”, and had the plot development in question not been announced ahead of time…and especially had Marvel issued fake solicits for #161 onwards, this issue would REALLY and TRULY carry some emotional weight. But as it is, sure, we knew this was coming, it was only a matter as to how, and once we knew that he gets shot and that the feasome five show up at his house, well, we knew how it was going to happen as well.

  3. “Ye”? So John Constantine is either in the process of mutating into a Marvel Asgardian, or into an Irishman.

  4. Hey now Mr McMillan, I sure hope your dog is okay now. Sad pets are really…affecting, aren’t they?

    Spider-Man died?!?! Say what now!

  5. I actually read the Canterbury Cricket, and I can’t really agree with you Graeme…

    …because Green Arrow Industries was so much worse.

Leave a Reply


− 2 = one